You can be fired for sending these WhatsApp messages in South Africa

In South Africa, WhatsApp’s convenience for workplace communication is undeniable, but the platform’s casual nature can lead to significant legal and professional risks.

Messages sent on WhatsApp, whether in professional groups or private conversations, can result in dismissal or even criminal charges if they violate workplace standards or national laws.

Several real-world cases illustrate the dangers of WhatsApp misuse.

A notable case involved an employee of a Johannesburg-based logistics firm who was dismissed after sharing disparaging comments about their manager in a work-related WhatsApp group.

The messages, meant as jokes, were interpreted as undermining authority and damaging workplace morale.

The employer argued that the conduct violated company policies on professionalism and respect.

When the case reached the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation, and Arbitration (CCMA), the dismissal was upheld, emphasising that employees are accountable for their conduct on digital platforms.

In another case, an educator at a Gauteng school shared explicit content in a private WhatsApp group meant for teachers.

The material was inadvertently forwarded to a parent, sparking outrage among the school community.

The teacher was dismissed for gross misconduct, with the school arguing that the content breached its code of ethics and harmed its reputation.

The CCMA supported the dismissal, stating that educators are held to high standards of conduct, even in private communication.

Legal experts like Wright Rose-Innes note that dismissals for WhatsApp messages hinge on specific criteria.

Employers must establish that the employee violated a valid workplace rule, was aware of this rule, and that dismissal is a proportionate response.

While South African labour law ensures fairness in dismissal processes, employees remain bound by their duty of good faith toward their employers.

Practical examples reinforce the importance of responsible WhatsApp use.

Messages that mock colleagues, reveal sensitive company information, or convey personal grievances can jeopardise careers.

Employers have the right to take disciplinary action if such content disrupts workplace harmony or damages their reputation.

Beyond workplace cases, South Africa’s legal landscape highlights other risks associated with WhatsApp messages.

For example, under the Cybercrimes Act of 2021, a member of Operation Dudula, a xenophobic vigilante group, was arrested in Durban for circulating voice notes inciting violence against foreign nationals.

These recordings encouraged South Africans to seize foreign-owned businesses, violating provisions of the Act that criminalise incitement to violence.

The accused pleaded guilty to the charges and was fined R10,000, avoiding a lengthy trial.

This case demonstrates how WhatsApp can be a tool for hate speech and criminal incitement, holding users legally accountable for harmful content.

Additionally, the Preventing and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill, signed into law in 2024, further tightens restrictions.

Under this law, hate speech is defined as the intentional distribution of content that incites hatred based on attributes like race, religion, or gender.

Violators can face imprisonment, fines, or both.

In one high-profile incident, a business executive was prosecuted for sharing a racist meme in a private WhatsApp group.

Though the executive claimed it was a joke, the court ruled it violated hate speech laws, leading to a hefty fine and reputational damage.

Workplace rules often intersect with social media policies, making professional WhatsApp groups particularly precarious.

In one case, an employee at a Cape Town advertising agency shared confidential client information in a WhatsApp group, believing it would remain private.

The message was leaked, jeopardising the agency’s relationship with the client. The employee was dismissed, with the CCMA affirming the decision as a breach of trust and confidentiality.

These cases underscore a key message: WhatsApp messages, whether professional or personal, are not immune from scrutiny.

South African labour law requires employers to establish that dismissals for WhatsApp misconduct are based on fair procedures and valid reasons.

This includes proving the existence of workplace rules and demonstrating that employees were aware of these rules.

However, employees must recognise that digital communication is subject to workplace codes of conduct and national laws.

To mitigate risks, employers should implement clear policies regarding WhatsApp use, ensuring employees understand boundaries and consequences.

Employees, on the other hand, must exercise caution, particularly when expressing opinions, sharing sensitive material, or posting content that could be construed as harmful.

In today’s digital age, WhatsApp has become an integral part of South African professional and social life.

However, as these cases show, the platform’s ease of use comes with significant responsibilities.

Missteps can lead to dismissal, criminal charges, or reputational harm, making it essential to navigate this communication tool with care and accountability.

Read: New payment system coming to FNB, Standard Bank, Nedbank and more next week