Built for the long, bumpy road: rethinking how businesses finance fleet vehicles
By Raymond Schulz, Head of Fleet, Merchant West
South African businesses are making fleet decisions under real pressure.
Interest rates have kept financing expensive, current fuel costs are unpredictable, and margins are tight enough that every rand spent upfront gets scrutinised.
In such an environment, a lower purchase price is an easy decision to justify today.
New entrant vehicle brands are gaining ground for exactly this reason, with aggressive pricing and specifications that look competitive on paper.
The vehicle price is only one part of the calculation. Other factors on future risk also play a part when the total life cycle cost of the deal within the financing options enters the picture.
Why the uncertainty gap narrows when you lease
When a business buys outright, the full price difference between a new entrant and an established brand sits on its balance sheet from day one.
When a business leases, the monthly cost is based on actual usage, reflecting the price minus what the vehicle is expected to be worth at the end of the term, and not the full purchase price.
Established brands hold their value at resale in a way newer entrants haven’t yet had the years on the road to prove.
Based on what we’re seeing across our own fleet book, an established brand can still retain higher resale values than a comparably priced new entrant over a similar term.
This narrows the monthly cost difference between the two far more than the purchase price ever suggested.
A full maintenance lease bundles in scheduled maintenance, tyres and annual licence renewal, including fleet administration and unpredictable costs that the ownership option requires separate budgeting for.
A business comparing purchase price against a lease quote is rarely comparing like-for-like once all fleet costs are accounted for, including those excluded in the upfront vehicle-only price checks.
The smaller operator
A business running two or three vehicles feels this most acutely.
It carries the same maintenance and servicing costs as a larger fleet, just without the scale to handle the administration of this and absorb them.
These costs are significant relative to a small operation’s cash flow when they arrive unpredictably rather than as a planned monthly line.
Leasing an established brand currently converts that unpredictability into a known monthly cost, at a price point closer to a new entrant than buying ever allowed.
It can only work for a business if the terms move with the business.
A client using more mileage because business is strong should see the deal adjusted to match.
One going through a slower period should see costs come down rather than face a fixed cost penalty for it.
Merchant West structures a deal around how a client is genuinely operating and stays in that conversation for the life of the deal.
The larger fleet
For a business running thirty or forty vehicles, the same logic compounds across the whole fleet. We’ve seen this play out directly.
Clients who added new entrant vehicles to their fleets have come back partway through the term asking to switch those vehicles out for other brands after running into reliability or unknown issues, versus a mature local supply chain.
That’s not a hypothetical cost, it’s businesses paying in downtime and then paying again to correct the decision.
What happens if you decide to own
Some clients start on a lease and later want to convert to ownership.
A client moving from a lease on an established brand into ownership inherits an asset that will hold its value at resale down the line.
A client who bought a new entrant outright from the start doesn’t get that option.
They will carry this fixed cost and an unknown resale position with no lease extension structure to fall back onto.
Play the long game
Under pressure, it’s tempting to make the decision that looks best this month.
The businesses that come out ahead aren’t the ones chasing the lowest number today, they’re the ones building toward where they want to be down the road.
Leasing an established brand preserves capital that would otherwise sit tied up in a depreciating asset, freeing it for what the business needs to grow.
Not to mention that lease rentals are typically tax deductible as an operating expense, and present cashflow benefits.
South African businesses don’t need to sell themselves short to survive a tough economy. They need to make the decision that still looks smart in five years, not just this month.
Merchant West works with fleet operators of every size to structure finance around the full life of the vehicle and the real shape of their business, helping them turn ambition into reality without carrying risk they can’t calculate.
Funding products vary between full maintenance leasing, operating leases and dynamic leases (lease to ownership) to present flexible and cost-effective choices to suit different balance sheet and cashflow needs.
Click here to request a fleet consultation with Merchant West.
Loading ...