The one thing businesses want from coalitions in South Africa
As political parties continue to negotiate coalition agreements for the 138 hung councils that must elect leadership this week, business groups are putting stability at the top of their wish lists.
According to Business Leadership South Africa (BLSA) chief executive Busi Mavuso, the leadership teams elected this week will shape the future of their municipalities.
Crucially, they will shape service delivery, investment and jobs, she said, and for this, stability is vital.
“Workers and ratepayers alike require councils that can make decisions effectively and ensure the execution of turnaround plans,” Mavuso said.
“Those must be executed over years, by leaders who stay long enough to see them through.”
The business leader said that the instability felt by the City of Johannesburg, which has had 10 mayoral changes since 2016, should be avoided.
Last week, the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Velenkosini Hlabisa, published the Guidelines for Stable Coalitions in Local Government.
The guidelines are a framework to help build stable coalitions across the country. Unfortunately, they are not legally binding.
There are laws that are currently being processed—the Municipal Structures Amendment Bill—which will have a more structured basis for coalitions, but these are not yet in effect.
The laws were approved by cabinet in August and are before Parliament, but they were not passed in time to govern the coalitions now being formed.
Mavuso said this was a missed opportunity.
“The Bill sets sensible rules for stable executive and political leadership in councils. The guidelines are a second-best substitute,” she said.
The guidelines anticipate the legislation and provide municipalities with a way to begin complying now, she added.
“They also urge councils to amend their rules to prevent the abuse of motions of no confidence, which have been the main instrument of instability.”
Mavuso said the guidelines set a benchmark against which voters can measure their representatives, but they help only insofar as political parties agree to follow them.
“Every party in a coalition should commit publicly to the guidelines and publish its coalition agreement,” she said.
“That would show voters that parties are prepared to give up back-room deals in exchange for stability, and show business that it can rely on municipal leadership.”
The business leader said that Parliament should focus on passing the bill so that the next round of coalition-building happens under rules with force.
“That would give business and voters confidence in their political leadership and democracy,” she said.