Gordhan says analysts ‘lack insight and financial literacy’ over SAA bailout

Public Enterprises minister, Pravin Gordhan, has welcomed the government’s commitment to provide R10.5 billion to be used to finalise the Business Rescue Plan (BRP) and restructuring of South African Airways (SAA).

Presenting the medium-term budget policy statement (MTBPS) on Wednesday (28 October), finance minister Tito Mboweni said that Treasury would allocate R10.5 billion to SAA to implement its business rescue plan.

Analysts, economists, and opposition parties such as the Democratic Alliance (DA) have criticized the ongoing financial support for the insolvent airline.

Meanwhile, the World Bank has told South Africa’s government it has to cut its wage bill to qualify for a loan of as much as $2 billion and agree the money won’t be used to bail out insolvent state companies, Bloomberg reported, citing a person familiar with the situation.

Those conditions have stalled negotiations on the loan that began in April, the person said, asking not to be identified because the content of the discussions have not been made public. The World Bank said it will only comment if an agreement is reached.

However, in a statement on Thursday (29 October), the Department of Public Enterprises, citing Gordhan, slammed any critics of the latest bailout for the failed airline, taking particular aim at the DA.

“The minister is shocked and disappointed with the DA, other parties and some analysts’ lack of insight, financial literacy and understanding of governance processes. Worse, the DA ignores the suffering of SAA employees and the threat of losing their jobs,” the department said.

“In order to hide their knowledge of the aviation sector and its economics, the DA and their partners manipulate facts to fabricate false ideas about SAA.”

According to the ministry, the ‘facts’ include the following:

  • The Business Rescue Plan, concluded in line with section 151 of the Companies’ Act, has made the following recommendations:
    • A payment of a compromise dividend to the company’s concurrent creditors of R600 million which would equate to approximately 7.5 cents in the rand and payable over a three-years period;
    • A payment of approximately R1.7 billion to aircraft lessors, which is an equivalent of six months aircraft rental payments, again, payable over a three-year period;
    • The post-commencement creditors will be paid directly out of the working capital injection for the restart of the airline;
    • The lenders, inclusive of PCF lenders, will be paid as contemplated in the budget announced by the minister of finance on 26 February 2020; and
    • Retrenchments, estimated to cost R2.2 billion, are contemplated which will result in one thousand employees being retained by the company and such retrenchments will be pursued through either the Leadership Consultation Forum or section 189 process of the Labour Relations Act.

The minister said that the plan contemplates the following:

  • An initial working capital injection of R2.8 billion of which R800 million is for the payment of Post-commencement Creditors;
  • Retrenchment costs of R2.2 billion;
  • A provision for un-flown tickets of R3 billion required in the medium term; and
  • Payment to creditors, other than lenders, in the amount of R2.2 billion.

“The plan is also premised on government’s commitment to fund the finalisation of the business rescue plan, hence finance minister Tito Mboweni’s announcement that R10.5 billion has been allocated to SAA to finalise the BRP process,” it said.

Further, the minister said that failure to allocate the funds would have resulted in the liquidation of the airline at the cost of more than R18.5 billion. Further, the liquidation would have meant that SAA employees would have been worse off and received a maximum of approximately R32,000 per staff member, regardless of years of service, to the extent that there are funds available.

They will only receive payment once the final liquidation and distribution account has been approved which can take up to 24 months.

The ministry said it believes that the completion of the business rescue process is the only viable alternative to a viable and sustainable national carrier – one which supports job preservation and the ability to bring the airline back from the brink to a position where employees, suppliers, and business partners can continue to contribute to the South African economy and its integration into the global economy.

The R10.5 billion, it said, will pave the way the finalisation of the business rescue process and restructuring of the airline through following activities:

  • Appointment of an Interim Board;
  • Appointment of an Interim chief executive officer and Interim Chief Financial
    Officer;
  • Implementation of a Social Plan – a training layoff scheme which will be facilitated by the Transport Education Training Authority in partnership with the Department of Labour and Employment;
  • Selection of a suitable Strategic Equity Partner to strengthen the launch of the new airline;
  • Settle the airline’s legacy debt, including voluntary severance packages to employees; and
  • Begin preparations for the formation of a new customer-centric airline designed to be lean, technology capable, digitally modernised and agile to service all market segments.

The department said it is engaging constructively towards the national interest objective of the formation of a new airline in the first half of 2021, “which will be run in a professional and sustainable manner to support key economic sectors – including tourism, and solidify South Africa as an African gateway to international markets”.

The ministry said it believes that the restructuring contained in the Business Rescue Plan for SAA is fundamental and will create a solid base for the emergence of a competitive, viable and sustainable national airline for the Republic of South Africa.

“The cumulative effect of these actions is that government will be partnering with the private sector in the launch and management of the new airline and relieving the financial burden from the fiscus.”


Read: Government defends SAA bailout as it seeks partners

Must Read

Partner Content

Show comments

Trending Now

Follow Us

Gordhan says analysts ‘lack insight and financial literacy’ over SAA bailout