SARS takes aim at PAYE in South Africa

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) has signalled an intensified focus on Pay-As-You-Earn (PAYE) compliance, marking it as a priority in the 2023/24 Annual Report.

This shift highlights SARS’s commitment to stricter oversight and greater accountability, particularly regarding employer tax responsibilities.

According to Tax Consulting SA, SARS has implemented a more rigorous auditing strategy aimed at ensuring that employers accurately withhold and remit PAYE.

Employers are now being urged to carefully assess their PAYE practices to confirm compliance with tax regulations.

In South Africa’s tax system, employers are central to PAYE collections, deducting tax directly from employees’ earnings on behalf of SARS.

SARS’s new approach places heightened emphasis on ensuring that these collections are conducted correctly and consistently.

Non-compliance, whether due to intentional missteps or accidental errors, is now more likely to draw scrutiny, as SARS is committed to tightening its PAYE collection processes.

For employers who may be uncertain about the adequacy of their PAYE practices, now is a crucial time to address any gaps proactively to prevent future complications.

Through its Specialised Audit division, SARS has expanded the scope of its audits to examine the PAYE compliance of both individuals and businesses.

This expanded audit framework not only addresses PAYE but also includes other employment-related tax considerations, such as the Employment Tax Incentive (ETI).

SARS auditors are well-trained and strategically prepared to detect non-compliance issues across different business models, whether through desk reviews or more intensive on-site audits.

This means that PAYE’s withholding accuracy is now under closer inspection, making compliance essential.

The focus of PAYE audits extends well beyond a cursory payroll review.

SARS is taking a comprehensive look at all components of PAYE withholding, including fringe benefits, the ETI, and any additional employee remuneration.

Proper reporting of fringe benefits—such as company cars or housing allowances—is now especially critical, as inaccuracies in these areas could result in further scrutiny and penalties.

For employers, this requires a diligent approach to ensure that every aspect of PAYE compliance is meticulously managed.

Alongside stricter audits, SARS has introduced a range of measures to help employers streamline compliance while maintaining closer oversight.

Recent updates include refined processes for tax directives, the bi-annual PAYE submissions (EMP501), and expanded eFiling capabilities for submitting third-party data.

These changes aim to make compliance more straightforward for employers while simultaneously giving SARS better visibility into reported PAYE data.

For many businesses, these adjustments may ease the procedural burdens of compliance, though they also underscore the need for careful adherence to updated standards.

Staying compliant with PAYE obligations is essential for employers who wish to avoid penalties or damage to their reputation.

Non-compliance, whether minor or significant, can have financial and reputational repercussions, especially in light of SARS’s recent advancements in both technology and staff training.

These improvements mean that discrepancies are more likely to be identified, making it increasingly important for employers to prioritise accurate and timely PAYE submissions.

For those uncertain about their compliance status, considering preemptive measures, such as consulting with tax experts or conducting internal compliance checks, could help mitigate any potential risks.

In sum, SARS’s renewed focus on PAYE compliance represents a significant step toward strengthening South Africa’s tax collection processes.

Employers who collect PAYE bear a vital responsibility in this system, and SARS’s new approach demonstrates a commitment to holding them accountable.

The enhanced auditing practices, along with updated compliance tools, are a clear signal for employers to revisit and verify their PAYE processes to remain in good standing.

As SARS continues to invest in its auditing capabilities, the importance of diligent, accurate PAYE practices has never been more critical for South African employers.

Read: The end of medical aid tax credits and new wealth taxes on the cards for South Africa