Rethinking academic integrity in the AI age: The case for moral functioning in online schools

In today’s online learning landscape, academic integrity has become a pressing concern, with schools and institutions scrambling to find effective ways to prevent cheating and plagiarism. The rise of artificial intelligence (AI) tools, like ChatGPT, has added complexity to this challenge.

Traditional methods such as proctoring software and online invigilation have proven to be less effective than hoped, with students often treating these measures as obstacles to outwit. To prepare learners for the future of work, forward-thinking schools, like Wingu Academy, are shifting focus toward sustainable, ethical solutions.

• Click here to learn more about Wingu Academy.

One such approach is the Four Component Model of Moral Functioning, which offers a far more meaningful and long-term strategy for fostering academic honesty and integrity.

The Challenge of Academic Integrity in Online Schools

The shift to online education has amplified academic integrity issues in various ways:

1. AI-powered Tools and Automation: With AI tools generating content and automating processes, students have access to unprecedented assistance, making it easier to bypass traditional assignments.
2. Flawed Proctoring Systems: Proctoring tools—such as webcam monitoring, browser locks, and facial recognition—are increasingly sophisticated, but so are students. Many see these tools as a challenge, rather than a deterrent, finding ways to circumvent them through VPNs, secondary devices, or other hacks.
3. Psychological Impact of Surveillance: Proctoring introduces a high-pressure environment where students feel distrusted and monitored, eroding their intrinsic motivation to learn and encouraging them to seek shortcuts. This reactive approach creates a toxic cycle of surveillance and resistance, rather than cultivating trust and ethical learning habits.

The Four Component Model of Moral Functioning: A Future-Oriented Solution

Wingu Academy is adopting the Four Component Model of Moral Functioning, developed by psychologist James Rest, as a core strategy to address academic integrity issues in the AI era. This model emphasises a deeper understanding of moral behaviour by focusing on four key dimensions that shape ethical decision-making:

1. Moral Sensitivity – The ability to recognise ethical issues and understand how one’s actions affect others.
2. Moral Judgement – The capacity to evaluate and make decisions based on ethical principles.
3. Moral Motivation – The prioritisation of moral values over personal gains or convenience.
4. Moral Character – The strength and persistence to follow through on ethical decisions, even when challenged.

Rather than merely policing student behaviour, this model aims to build a foundation for students to develop the capacity for ethical reasoning and decision-making on their own, fostering long-term moral growth.

Why Traditional Proctoring Methods Are Failing

The focus on proctoring and invigilation tools in online education has been largely reactive, targeting symptoms instead of addressing the underlying causes of unethical behaviour. Here’s why these methods fall short:

• Students Outpace Technology: No matter how advanced the proctoring software becomes, students often find ways to cheat the system.
• Eroding Trust and Relationships: Surveillance tools make students feel distrusted, pushing them to act defensively and undermining meaningful learning.
• Reduced Learning Autonomy: Rigid systems discourage the development of self-regulation and accountability, essential skills for both academic and professional success.
• Overemphasis on Detection vs. Prevention: These tools aim to catch misconduct rather than prevent it, missing the opportunity to shape ethical behaviour from the outset.

The Benefits of Fostering Moral Functioning for Academic Integrity

By focusing on moral functioning, online schools can nurture values-based learning environments where students are intrinsically motivated to act with integrity. This approach aligns with future workplace demands, where ethical decision-making and personal accountability are critical skills. The following are the key benefits of adopting the Four Component Model:

1. Prepares Students for the Future of Work: In professional settings, employees are expected to make ethical decisions independently. Cultivating moral functioning helps students build these lifelong skills early on.
2. Intrinsic Motivation for Integrity: Students who understand the moral implications of their actions are less likely to cheat, even when no one is watching.
3. Reduces Dependence on Surveillance: Instead of relying on external monitoring, students become self-regulated learners who are accountable for their performance.
4. Builds Trust and Community: A values-based culture fosters mutual respect between students and educators, strengthening relationships and promoting a positive learning environment.
5. Aligns with 21st-Century Education Goals: Teaching students how to think ethically prepares them for both academic success and responsible citizenship in a complex, interconnected world.

A New Path Forward: From Policing to Empowerment

Schools like Wingu Academy are leading the way by moving beyond surveillance and punitive measures toward a more empowering approach. The Four Component Model of Moral Functioning emphasises education over enforcement, helping students internalise values that promote academic integrity across all areas of life. With this shift, the school is not only combating academic misconduct but also developing critical soft skills like self-discipline, ethical reasoning, and empathy—skills that are increasingly in demand in the workplace.

AI and automation will continue to evolve, posing new challenges and opportunities for online education. However, by focusing on moral development, online schools can create sustainable systems that equip students to thrive in the AI age—not by outsmarting proctoring tools but by learning to make ethical decisions even when no one is watching.

Experience the Wingu Difference. Join our community today, and let your child discover the power of inclusive, personalised education. Because at Wingu Academy, every learner matters.

Visit our website for downloading the prospectus.

Contact us by

• Email: [email protected]
• Phone: 087 147 1668
• Book a one-on-one consultation session