Price war: Woolworths vs Spar vs Pick n Pay vs Checkers prices compared

Independent consumer website Retail Price Watch conducted a survey of prices across South Africa’s seven biggest chains, looking at prices in four different categories.

The chains were Cambridge Foods, Checkers, Makro, Pick n Pay, Shoprite, Spar and Woolworths, looking at the prices for baking ingredients, beverages, cereals and porridge, and staples.

According to Retail Price Watch’s findings, Pick n Pay was the least-cost winner in the baking ingredients category, with Woolworths a close second. Most expensive was Spar.

In the beverages category, Cambridge Foods was the winner with Shoprite, Woolworths and Pick n Pay all neck and neck for second place (less than R1 difference). Most expensive was Makro.

In the cereals and porridge category, Makro was the cheapest, with Pick n Pay coming second. Woolworths was the most expensive.

In the staples category, Cambridge Foods was the winner with Makro coming second. Woolworths was most expensive.

Baking ingredients

Baking Ingredients Cambridge Checkers Makro PnP Shoprite Spar Woolworths
Nestle Caramel Treat Can 360g R25.99 R24.17 R20.99 R23.69 R26.29 R28.97 R21.62
Nestle Condensed Milk Can 385g R21.65 R22.41 R18.95 R19.96 R22.21 R22.99 R20.28
Danone Ultramel Custard 1l R28.39 R27.30 R25.63 R24.55 R27.18 R27.98 R25.95
Snowflake Cake Flour 2.5kg R25.59 R25.87 R27.48 R23.81 R27.32 R29.95 R26.95
Maizena Cornflour 500g R17.89 R21.88 R20.33 R19.94 R20.18 R21.79 R17.95
Total R119.51 R121.63 R113.38 R111.95 R123.18 R131.68 R112.75

Beverages

Beverages Cambridge Checkers Makro PnP Shoprite Spar Woolworths
Nescafe Classic Jar 200g R74.99 R76.30 R67.97 R74.21 R77.56 R77.49 R71.62
Five Roses Tagless Black Tea 102 units R29.07 R30.21 R35.45 R30.63 R30.54 R34.57 R30.61
Joko Tagless Black Tea 100 units R26.26 R31.29 R39.95 R33.26 R31.99 R37.99 R31.95
Cremora 1kg R36.32 R40.71 R40.95 R38.89 R38.09 R37.09 R40.95
Freshpak Rooibos Tea 80 Units R25.99 R34.18 R36.95 R33.96 R32.42 R32.56 R34.95
Total R192.63 R212.69 R221.27 R210.95 R210.60 R219.70 R210.08

Cereals and Porridge

Cereals and Porridge Cambridge Checkers Makro PnP Shoprite Spar Woolworths
Bokomo Weetbix 900g R44.49 R48.18 R44.95 R42.93 R47.54 R47.59 R44.95
Bokomo Weetbix 900g R47.49 R48.08 R44.45 R49.47 R51.10 R49.29 R51.95
Jungle Oats 1kg R22.65 R27.09 R24.63 R25.12 R26.84 R27.74 R27.28
Jungle OatsoEasy 10 units R39.99 R38.88 R37.45 R37.40 R37.99 R39.59 R42.95
Kelloggs Corn Flakes Value Pack2 R39.99 R41.77 R32.48 R35.80 R41.97 R42.89 R42.95
Total R194.61 R204.00 R183.96 R190.72 R205.44 R207.10 R210.08

Staples

Staples Cambridge Checkers Makro PnP Shoprite Spar Woolworths
Selati White Sugar 2.5kg R32.29 R33.69 R33.00 R34.32 R34.86 R32.77 R35.45
Iwisa Super Maize Meal 2.5kg R23.59 R26.65 R23.95 R25.73 R27.24 R26.74 R27.95
Lucky Star Pilchards in Tomato Sauce 400g R15.19 R17.38 R15.95 R17.17 R16.13 R17.88 R17.95
Spekko Parboiled Rice 2kg R22.31 R24.56 R24.28 R25.40 R25.24 R25.65 R26.95
Rama 500g Brick R23.79 R23.88 R23.28 R24.87 R20.71 R26.32 R24.99
Total R117.17 R126.16 R120.46 R127.49 R124.18 R129.36 R133.29

“No store can claim to be the cheapest across all categories. Consumers should not believe that lots of ‘Specials’ mean the store has the best prices for everything,” said Viccy Baker of Retail Price Watch.

“When adding together all 20 items in the different categories, Cambridge Foods is the overall winner, with Spar the most expensive. However, there is less than 11% difference between the cost of the identical basket in Cambridge Foods and Spar.”

“There is only R3 difference between the prices of the same goods in Shoprite, Checkers and Woolworths, for example,” Baker said.

Totals

# Shop Total
1 Cambridge R623.92
2 Makro R639.07
3 Pick n Pay R641.11
4 Shoprite R663.40
5 Checkers R664.48
6 Woolworths R666.20
7 Spar R687.84

According to Baker, stores keep an eye on each other’s prices and alter them on a weekly or even daily basis.

“Unfortunately today it is all about the stores manipulating their statistics on consumer behaviour to extract the last cent rather than simply ensuring that shoppers consistently get the best value for money,” she said.

Baker said that her research sees prices moving up and downwards by as much as 50% in a single week.

The items surveyed are national brands which were selected solely on the basis that they are available from all seven chains. The average price of each item in June and July from stores around the country was used in order to ensure that a single “special” did not unduly weight the overall price of the item.

Viccy Baker is founder of Red Gekko’s Retail Price Watch, a consumer website dedicated to providing the latest up-to-date information on consumer good prices across South Africa. You can view and compare products on various prices here.

More on retail

How much money you save when you buy household goods in bulk in SA

Consumers are in serious trouble

Consumers cut living expenses, but aren’t saving

This is what stressed-out South Africans are willing to sacrifice to cut costs

Latest news

Partner Content

Show comments

Recommended