Shoprite blows Woolworths, Spar, and Pick n Pay out the water

Shoprite has emerged as the clear leader among South Africa’s major retailers in terms of share price performance over the past year, significantly outperforming its competitors.

Shoprite’s share price rose from R248 per share in November 2023 to R308.80 in November 2024, delivering an impressive 24.5% return for investors.

This solid growth reflects the company’s strong operational performance and strategic positioning, particularly within its core South African market, where it continues to capture consumer spending.

The group’s success is rooted in its ability to adapt to market demands and expand its offerings, including innovations like the Sixty60 delivery service, which has seen massive growth.

With total revenue nearing R250 billion for the 52 weeks ending 30 June 2024, Shoprite remains South Africa’s largest retailer.

Its supermarket operations alone recorded an additional R21.4 billion in sales compared to the previous year.

CEO Pieter Engelbrecht highlighted the group’s transformation, noting that while it once took nearly two decades to achieve R10 billion in revenue, it now generates the same amount every 15 days.

This monumental growth reflects its operational efficiency and dominance across various market segments, including Checkers and Checkers Hyper stores.

Meanwhile, Pick n Pay, despite facing numerous challenges, managed to achieve a year-on-year share price increase of 14.8%, climbing from R21.95 to R25.20.

The retailer’s financial struggles are evident, with a R3.2 billion after-tax loss for the year ending February 2024.

This was driven by a R2.8 billion non-cash impairment on its grocery segment, among other operational hurdles.

However, the group has shown resilience through strategic initiatives such as a R4 billion rights offer to shore up its balance sheet and plans for an IPO of its Boxer brand, which has been a strong performer.

These measures indicate a focus on long-term stability, even as CEO Sean Summers warns of potential short-term pain.

Spar’s share price also experienced growth, albeit more modestly, with a 9.7% increase over the past year.

The group has faced challenges, including a problematic SAP system implementation at its distribution centre, which disrupted operations.

However, Spar has signalled a potential turnaround, with a 4.1% increase in turnover for the 47 weeks ending 23 August 2024 and a renewed focus on improving its South African business.

The sale of its loss-making Polish division further reinforces Spar’s commitment to streamlining operations and focusing on core markets.

Woolworths, on the other hand, was the only major retailer to experience a year-on-year decline in share price, dropping 6.1% from R71.51 to R67.10.

Known as the premium retailer among the four, Woolworths has struggled against a backdrop of economic pressures in both South Africa and Australia.

For the financial year ending 30 June 2024, the group reported a decline in operating profit from R6.6 billion to R6.0 billion and a 30% drop in headline earnings per share.

Challenges such as port congestion, taxi strikes, and Avian flu in South Africa, coupled with high interest rates and reduced consumer spending in Australia, weighed heavily on the group’s performance.

While Woolworths maintains a loyal customer base, these external pressures have dampened profitability and investor confidence.

The divergence in share price performance among these retailers underscores the varying degrees of resilience and strategic adaptability within the sector.

Shoprite’s ability to consistently innovate and expand its market share has solidified its position as the leader, while Pick n Pay and Spar strive to recover from operational challenges and financial setbacks.

Woolworths, despite its strong brand equity, has found itself vulnerable to external economic forces that have eroded profitability.

The year has highlighted the importance of agility, operational excellence, and strategic foresight in navigating South Africa’s complex retail landscape.

Read: South Africans are dumping DStv