Best and worst banks in SA: reputation survey

FNB is the bank with the best reputation in South Africa, followed by ABSA, Standard Bank and Nedbank, according to a new survey.

The RepTrak Pulse survey is conducted annually by collecting over 3,000 ratings from the economically active segments of the general public in Gauteng, KwaZulu-Natal, Western Cape and the Eastern Cape.

Only companies which form part of Financial Mail’s 2011 top 20 Companies listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) were surveyed.

Local companies suffer from poor reputation

According to the RepTrak Pulse survey results, Africa’s top companies suffered a “bloodbath” in their reputations this year, with only retailer Woolworths emerging with a strong and robust reputation score.

“A lack of visible business leadership emerges as the main cause for declining confidence in corporate South Africa,” said the Reputation Institute’s South African Managing Director, Dominik Heil.

“Our corporate business leaders see themselves as running a slick operation that produces returns, and that’s where it stops. We have a vacuum in visible leaders that are prepared to stand up for a certain vision of society despite the fact that the companies they lead are having a significant effect on vast segments of the population and the nation as a whole.”

With its score of 78.59, indicating a strong/robust reputation, Woolworths has way and above the best reputation among South Africa’s top twenty listed companies.

It scored nearly ten points more than runner-up, MTN and topped all seven reputation drivers – products and services, innovation, performance, citizenship, workplace, governance, and leadership.

The remaining nineteen companies scored below 70 points, including last year’s top four companies – MTN, ABSA, Old Mutual and Standard Bank – giving them “average/moderate” reputations.

SA Banks

The reputations of all big South African Banks have marginally decreased. Overall ABSA achieved third place, with Standard Bank in 4th and Nedbank in 8th.

FNB has the best reputation among the South African banks, but was not rated among the top 20 listed companies, as it is a wholly-owned subsidiary, and is not listed.

“The declining reputations in the banking sector are more moderate than in the other industries and the country’s financial sector continued to perform well in comparison to its global counterparts, which tend to score poorly amongst their respective audiences,” said the Reputation Institute.

The scores of the top twenty listed companies in the 2012 Reputation Pulse were as follows:

Rank Company Rating
1 Woolworths 78.59
2 MTN 69.57
3 ABSA 69.12
4 Standard Bank 67.79
5 Vodacom 67.53
6 Clicks 67.12
7 Old Mutual 65.08
8 Nedbank 65.07
9 Spar 64.84
10 Pick n Pay 64.31
11 Sasol 61.97
12 Shoprite 61.93
13 Tiger Brands 58.04
14 Sanlam 57.24
15 SABMiller 56.66
16 Anglo American 53.85
17 Telkom 51.55
18 Santam 48.98
19 Liberty Holdings 48.49
20 BHP Billiton 40.22

Related articles

Survey reveals most satisfied internet banking customers

Best and worst banks in South Africa: consumer survey

Withdrawal fees – how SA banks stack up

Latest news

Partner Content

Show comments

Recommended