Legal warning for South Africans with dogs
While noisy neighbours can be incredibly frustrating, there are laws in South Africa that can help keep one’s home peaceful.
“Late-night music, barking dogs, and even regular domestic rows are disturbances that can negatively impact your health and well-being,” said legal expert Cor Van Deventer, Director at VDM Incorporated.
One’s right to a peaceful environment is still protected by the Environment Conservation Act and local municipal by-laws, but this depends on the type of noise.
The first is disturbing noise, which can be measured in decibels, such as music, power tools, and machinery.
The second is noise nuisance, which is more subjective and can refer to noise that disturbs the peace for an extended period, such as incessant barking from dogs.
Municipal by-laws often specify acceptable noise levels for different zones and times.
One case, Laskey and Another v Showzone CC and Others, saw noise and other complaints made by residents about a theatre-restaurant in Cape Town.
The court found that the respondent’s roof and roof gallery had not been acoustically insulated, and as a result, the respondent was prohibited from conducting business until effective measures were put in place.
The first respondent was also directed to pay the applicants’ legal expenses, including the costs incurred from setting the hearing down as a matter of urgency.
Noise nuisance can include dogs that bark constantly, loud music, shouting, or frequent parties.
The court will consider factors such as noise, duration, and the time and place it occurs.
An extreme case was presented in the High Court, involving the City of Cape Town and a dog-related business.
The business was found to be in breach of noise regulations, amid incessant barking that constituted a nuisance.
The business was also granted a cease order, essentially meaning that it had to close down.
“It’s important to realise that the law recognises that certain noise levels are part of communal living, especially in urban areas,” said Van Deventer.
“But when the noise becomes unreasonable, frequent, and disruptive, you have the right to take action.”
What you can do
If you have a problem with noise levels, the best first step is to talk with your neighbour.
If the neighbour is uncooperative or simply ignores a request, it may be best to take a formal approach.
Options include sending a complaint to the local municipality, outlining the nuisance, citing the relevant by-laws and creating an official record that can be used later.
“The process can, however, be slow and at times ineffective,” warned Van Deventer.
Another option is to approach a mediator, who can facilitate a structured discussion to help both parties reach a reasonable compromise, which can save time and minimise confrontation.
The final recourse is to apply for a court interdict through an attorney.
“An interdict is a powerful court order that legally compels your neighbour to stop the noise.”
“To do this, the application must contain evidence such as a detailed log of the noise incidents, witness statements, recordings, and a statement about the negative impact it’s having on your life.”
If a neighbour ignores a court interdict, they may be held in contempt of court. A criminal offence may also result in a hefty fine or jail time.
If you can show demonstrable harm, including health problems or financial loss, you may also be able to sue for damages.
Loading ...