mobile menu mobile search

The truth about South Africa’s “jobs bloodbath”

The truth about South Africa’s “jobs bloodbath”

Labour market economist Dr Neva Makgetla says that data from Stats SA showing the country lost 355,000 jobs in the first quarter of 2016 is likely exaggerated.

Earlier this month, Stats SA published it Quarterly Labour Force Survey for Q1 2016, showing a massive jump in the country’s unemployment rate – from 24.5% in Q4 2015, to 26.7% in 2016.

Contributing to this big jump was the loss of 355,000 jobs between the quarters.

According to a report put out by Makgetla this week, however, there is some doubt whether so many jobs were actually lost, as it is unlikely that this kind of ‘jobs bloodbath’ could have occurred without significantly more impact on communities and workers.

“So what is really going on? The short answer is that we can’t tell (how many jobs were really lost) because of statistical problems,” the economist said.

According to Makgetla, for its latest Quarterly Labour report, Stats SA shifted to a new master sample, which would have skewed the data.

“It’s likely that the reported jobs crash reflects a more realistic estimate of employment levels following four quarters of exaggerated figures (from the previous sample),” she said.

“Statistics South Africa reported in the QLFS documentation that, in the first quarter of 2015, it changed the master sample to reflect findings from the 2011 Census. That is, it essentially re-weighted its sample, which covers around 30,000 households every quarter.”

“It seems likely that the uptick in employment figures for 2015 resulted from this shift, rather than from unusually rapid job creation. It is not clear whether some further modification in the sampling frame led to the correction in the first quarter of 2016.”

According to Makgetla, the trends reported for mining and agriculture employment in 2015 were particularly striking and also added weight to her view.

For both sectors, the QLFS found substantial jobs growth in 2015 despite the end of the commodity boom and the drought.

Moreover, in the first quarter of 2015, with the introduction of the new master sample in 2015, the QLFS found that agricultural employment increased from 740,000 to 890,000 – some 20% growth in a single quarter.

“While it is likely that employment creation has been affected by the broader economic slowdown, the sharp job losses reported for the first quarter of 2016 seem highly unlikely. Rather, they seem to have resulted largely from the shift to a new sampling frame,” the economist said.

More on unemployment

Radical transformation will solve SA unemployment: Black Business Council

High unemployment in SA is apartheid’s fault: Zuma

Massive jump in South African unemployment rate


BusinessTech's Staff Writer is directly plugged into the South African Internet backbone, and spits out press releases and other news as they receive it. They are believed to be cl...
TAGS: Headline
Join the Conversation
  • James Dean

    Even if no jobs were lost, the ANC still has to answer as to why they failed on their promises.

  • Konstabel Koekemoer

    I tend to agree with Dr Makgetla that previous stats were probably over optimistic and we are now seeing a more realistic picture. I think the reality is even worse though if you were to include the large number of illegal immigrants and other ‘unregistered’ people that have no jobs.

  • Mike

    So…. is he calling Stats SA a liar?

    • NeonPigeon

      No, he is saying: “Stats SA shifted to a new master sample, which would have skewed the data”.

      • So not lies, but damned lies?

        • NeonPigeon

          exactly – though one would have to ask what the motivation for the government is for lying in that direction.

  • Ethan

    He is missing the point 350 000 jobs is a scary figure irrespective of the period that it occured. More crime in SA……..

  • Runnin Bare

    Labour laws are one of the biggest hiccups but Govt are scared to revise them for fear of the unions (who only look after their own interests). Let the employees have some job responsibility that will increase production. Two words made USA and China….”you’re fired”.
    Of course the other problem is unstable political situation in SA. These are the two most mentioned by overseas investors.

  • Wyzak

    So basically the 300k jobs were lost in the last quarter, but were lost in the last few years under the ANCs watch.

  • Stevo Jones

    That’s great news! So everything under the anc is just getting better then?

    Bull. Just look outside for one minute to see just how bad things are getting.

  • TellMe

    Why not use the R4 billion set aside for the pimp plane to take some of those unemployed people and give them some more skills, like I don’t know, small business management and give them some starting capital. That will give each of those 355k about R11267.60, more than enough for a few short courses at Unisa and a little startup capital.

Join our newest FREE BusinessTech newsletter today!
×